5 Strained Tomatoes Substitutes You Should Try

strained tomatoes substitute, substitutes for strained tomatoes, strained tomatoes

Strained Tomatoes Substitutes

strained tomatoes substitute, substitutes for strained tomatoes, strained tomatoes


Tomatoes used for cooking come in different forms and even tastes and flavors, some are tinned, some are crushed, some are strained and more, while they are all from the same vegetable, their effects on meals tend to be different from the other that is why when one is looking for a substitute for strained tomatoes they must concentrate on the best strained tomatoes substitute that would not much be different from strained tomatoes in either taste or flavors.

Helping cooks achieve their aim of replacing strained tomatoes in their recipes and still produce the best result is the target of this article about substituting strained tomatoes.


What are strained tomatoes?

Perhaps you don’t know what strained tomatoes is or this is your first time of hearing about it.

Do you enjoy the flavor of fresh tomatoes, and detest their seeds and skin? You’ll like strained tomatoes if that’s the case.

Fresh tomatoes’ flesh is pureed after the seeds and peel have been removed, creating strained tomatoes. As a result, you get a thick, silky sauce that works well in many kinds of recipes.

Strained tomatoes are short-cooked, pureed, and sieved tomatoes, usually bottled or packed in tetra-pack containers. Strained tomatoes can work out in any recipe of your choice.

So, if you recently stocked your house with some strained tomatoes the last time you went grocery shopping, now that it’s time to use it, you discover you’re out of strained tomatoes.

The essence of explaining what strained tomato is, is to make it easy to understand and identify especially for budding cooks who just got to know of it or see it mentioned on a cooking tutorial elsewhere.

Substitutes For Strained Tomatoes

Tomato Puree

strained tomatoes substitute, substitutes for strained tomatoes, strained tomatoes

A thick liquid called tomato purée is produced by boiling and straining tomatoes. Tomato sauce, tomato paste, and tomato purée differ in consistency; tomato puree is thicker and has a more flavorful flavor than sauce.

They are made by blending and cooking very fresh and ripe tomatoes until it is sour. Tomato puree frequently serves as a foundation for additional sauces, soups, or as an element in other foods. If you want to make tomato puree at home, you can cook tomatoes until they are mushy and put them through a food mill or strainer.

Tomato puree is one of the best substitutes for strained tomatoes in your recipe. You can also see some of the best substitutes for tomato puree for when you need to replace tomato puree.

Whole Peeled Tomatoes

strained tomatoes substitute, substitutes for strained tomatoes, strained tomatoes

Whole peeled tomatoes are obtained by peeling and preserving whole tomatoes in puree, sea salt, citric acid, calcium chloride, and tomato juice. The thinnest tomatoes are whole, peeled ones; the next thickest are chopped, then crushed.

And that is how whole peeled tomatoes are produced and you can now use them in place of strained tomatoes in any recipe. Whole peeled tomatoes is also a good substitute for strained tomatoes in your recipe.

Tomato paste and water

This is one of the easiest to make and use substitutes for strained tomatoes. All you need to do is mix tomato paste and water. Mix 1 part tomato paste and 2 parts water until a smooth mixture is formed if you want to create your tomato paste recipe yourself.

This mixture will be similar to strained tomatoes in terms of thickness and texture and will definitely come out nice in your recipe.

Crushed Tomatoes

strained tomatoes substitute, substitutes for strained tomatoes, strained tomatoes

Crushed tomatoes are ripe tomatoes that have been precisely chopped. Although they can also be crushed, diced tomatoes typically feel smoother than crushed tomatoes.

If you have crushed tomatoes that already have salt in them, be careful when adding salt to your meal. Crushed tomatoes that are labeled ‘peeled’ or ‘triple washed’ are usually the most suitable to use because they are free of harsh chemicals that can be harmful to you or that can destroy your recipe.

Crushed tomatoes are considered by cooks to be one of the best substitutes for strained tomatoes.


Those are some of the most popular and widely used and accepted substitutes for strained tomatoes, the list is short because these are exactly what cooks prefer to use when replacing strained tomatoes in their recipes. In the following section I would be answering some frequently asked questions about substituting strained tomatoes in your recipe.


FAQs About Strained Tomatoes Substitutes

No, tomato sauce are not the same as strained tomatoes, strained tomatoes are your normal tomatoes that have had their water/.juice removed from them.

  • Can I substitute strained tomatoes for tomato sauce?

Yes, you can substitute strained tomatoes for tomato sauce in your recipe by blending the strained tomatoes till it has the fine consistency you desire in tomato sauce.

  • How do you make strained tomatoes at home?

You make strained tomatoes at home by following the below steps:

  1. Wash and cut the tomatoes in half.
  2. Remove the inner seeds by gently squeezing them.
  3. Place the tomato halves in a large pot and cook and stair over low heat for 30 minutes.
  4. Add salt and stair occassionally.
  5. Transfer them to a food mill and gradually strain the water out of it. Do this with a little quantity of tomato each time.
  6. Turn the strained tomatoes to a bowl. You’ve made your strained tomatoes at home.
  • How do you strain tomatoes without a food mill?

To strain tomatoes without food mill, make use of a food mesh with the ability for fine texture. Fine mesh works just as good as food mill.

  • Can I use a strainer instead of a food mill?

Yes you can use strainers instead of food mill when making strained tomatoes at home.


Like & Follow Us On Facebook

You May Also Like