15 Substitutes For Heavy Cream In Pasta That Makes It Creamy

Heavy Cream Substitute For Pasta

Heavy cream is the homogenized mixture of fresh milk and milk fat that collects on top of fresh milk. It is one of the richest types of liquid cream available to consumers. Heavy cream has a fat content of 36% to 40% with the remaining part being normal fresh milk. The milk fat and milk have been emulsified and mixed thoroughly so that they can’t be separated in heavy cream.

As for nutritional value, heavy cream is just like many dairy products. It has some useful nutrients like protein, vitamin A, and vitamin D, and useful minerals like calcium, potassium, and phosphorus. However, it is not a rich source as you will need to consume a lot of heavy cream to gain these nutrients in any significant amount. 

Over the years, heavy cream has been used as an ingredient when making different recipes and dishes like pasta and many more. It can help take the taste and feeling of those meals to a next level. There are times you might want some heavy cream substitute for pasta, at such times, this article becomes incredibly important and useful.

Now, what happens when you’re about to make the creamy pasta dish, only to find out that you have run out of heavy cream? You must be thinking about a substitute you can use in place of heavy cream in your pasta and I’m here to help you out.

As mentioned earlier, this article is about the 15 best substitutes for heavy cream in pasta so you can use as an alternative to heavy cream. Know that none of these substitutes are going to be a perfect replacement for heavy cream but they will add that creamy feeling to your pasta. You should also know there are some heavy cream substitutes for soups.

Substitute For Heavy Cream In Pasta

• Evaporated milk

Evaporated milk is a dairy product that is obtained after the water content in fresh milk has been removed through the process of evaporation. Evaporated milk is thicker and creamy than fresh whole milk which makes a good enough replacement for heavy cream when making pasta. Removing the water content makes evaporated milk have more concentrated nutrients and flavor when compared to whole milk.

A cup of evaporated milk will give you more nutrients than a cup of whole milk. Evaporated milk has a similar consistency to heavy cream so it is going to add richness and creaminess to your pasta recipe. Use about 1 cup of evaporated milk for every pound of pasta.

• Half-and-Half

Half and half is quite similar to heavy cream as they both have similar fat content. Half and Half is usually used when making coffee, tea, breakfast cereals, and other beverages.

Half and Half contains a mix of the nutrients and minerals one would get from milk and cream. It is a great source of folate, calcium, riboflavin, phosphorus, vitamin B12, and other useful nutrients and minerals that the human body needs. 

Half and Half is a good replacement for heavy cream when making pasta. It will help to add that creamy feeling that you’d usually get with heavy cream. Use one cup of half and a half to replace one cup of heavy cream. 

• Greek yogurt

Greek yogurt, known as strained yogurt, is a type of yogurt that has been strained to remove the liquid whey that is present in milk. After straining, greek yogurt now has a thicker consistency than normal yogurt but it still has the same unique sour taste that yogurt has. Greek yogurt is seen as a healthier alternative to normal yogurt as it has less sugar, less fat, and fewer calories. However, it has more protein which is a good thing as it is one of the few low-fat protein sources. 

Greek yogurt can help to replace heavy cream when you are making that pasta recipe. It will add richness and creaminess to the meal just like heavy cream would have added.

Use about 1 cup of greek yogurt for every pound of pasta but you can reduce or increase the amount based on your discretion. 

• Cream cheese

Cream cheese is a soft fresh cheese made from cream and milk, sometimes, stabilizers like carrageenan and carob bean gum are added. Cream cheese is usually used as a spread for crackers, bread, bagels, etc. It can be used when making salads, dipping sauce, and many more. Also, it can be used alongside other ingredients like yogurt to make spreads.

Cream cheese comes from the same family as heavy cream so it can be used in place of it when making pasta. It will make the meal creamy and will also bring the classic cheese flavor. Use cream cheese in the same amount as you would have used heavy cream.

• Cashew cream

If you are a vegetarian or someone who can consume dairy products, this is a great vegan alternative for you to use in place of heavy cream.

To make cashew cream, you need to blend raw cashews, and a bit of water to form a mixture with a thick consistency. Make the mixture with 75% cashews and 25% water. You can add extra virgin olive oil, lemon juice, and other ingredients if you want to add a certain taste. Cashew cream is very nutritious as it is a great source of magnesium, fiber, copper, and healthy monounsaturated fats. It is also free of cholesterol. 

The mixture is called cashew cream and it has a creamy and rich feeling just like heavy cream so it will work well as a substitute when you are making pasta. Use one cup of cashew cream to replace one cup of heavy cream.

• Cottage cheese

Cottage cheese is a dairy product made from milk curds and it has a mild flavor with a creamy, lumpy, and soupy texture. Cottage cheese still retains some of the whey in milk and the curds are not fully blended in.

Cottage cheese is one of the types of cheese that is common amongst people who eat healthily. It is a good source of protein with very low fat and calories. Cottage cheese can be used when making yogurt, salads, dipping sauce, and many more.

Cottage cheese is a great substitute option for anyone to use in place of heavy cream when making that delicious pasta recipe. Before using this, blend the cottage cheese to remove any lumps left in it. Now, use about 2 cups of cottage cheese for every pound of pasta.

• Vegan heavy cream

If you have non-dairy milk with you at home, then you can easily make a vegan heavy cream to replace normal heavy cream when making pasta.

To make this, you need to get your preferred non-dairy milk and melted vegan butter or extra virgin olive oil. Take two-thirds (⅔) cup of your non-dairy milk and one-third (⅓) cup of extra virgin olive oil or melted vegan butter, then mix them thoroughly till they are combined properly.

Now, you can use this homemade mixture in your creamy pasta recipe. Take one cup of this vegan heavy cream to replace one cup of normal heavy cream. 

• Crème fraiche

Créme fraîche is another dairy product and it is a type of sour cream that consists of about 10% to 45% of butterfat. It has a pH level of 4.5 and gets a sour taste after bacterial culture was added to the cream. 

Crème fraîche is quite similar to heavy cream as they both come from the same source except that crème fraîche has a sour taste due to the bacterial culture added. It is high in fat and calories so it is not the best choice if you like to eat healthily.

Crème fraîche has the same creamy texture that heavy cream has so it does a great job at being a substitute. When looking to use it, take a maximum of one cup for every pound of pasta.

• Non-dairy milk and cornstarch

This is another vegan option available to you if you are looking to replace heavy cream. You just need your preferred non-dairy milk and cornstarch. 

To make this, take one cup of non-dairy milk then add two tablespoons of cornstarch to it. Now, mix them thoroughly.

Now, you can use this mixture to add that creamy feeling to your pasta just like heavy cream would have. Don’t forget that it’s possible to substitute milk in cereals as well.

• Vegan sour cream

You can also use vegan sour cream when you are looking to replace heavy cream. It is very easy to make at home and you only need just 5 ingredients which are raw cashews, unsweetened non-dairy yogurt, lemon juice, apple cider vinegar, and salt.

Get the raw cashews, unsweetened non-dairy yogurt, lemon juice, apple cider vinegar, and salt into a blender and blend all of them together thoroughly. Once this is done, the mixture will be a bit soft but after about 2 hours in the fridge, it’ll firm up.

This has the same creamy, rich, and tangy taste that normal sour cream and it is a good alternative to use in place of heavy cream when making pasta. 

• White bean cream

This is one of the few uncommon options that we have on the list. If you’re a vegan, then this is something you’ll love.

To make this, blend cooked white beans, nutritional yeast, and vegetable broth to form a fine paste with a thick consistency. This mixture can be used to add creaminess to your pasta just like heavy cream. It is a very healthy option as white beans have a lot of useful nutrients and minerals that the body needs in it.

• Full fat coconut milk

Coconut milk is a liquid gotten from the grated pulp of mature coconuts. It has a milky white color and looks just like normal milk. Full-fat coconut has a high saturated fat content and a very rich taste with a nutty flavor. If you like the coconut flavor, then you can use this as a replacement for heavy cream when making pasta. It adds a creamy and rich feeling to your pasta just like heavy cream would.

Use about one cup of full-fat coconut milk for every pound of pasta.

That’s all the heavy cream substitute for pasta we are able to cover in this article, do not hesitate to mention any worthy alternative that was missed. In the next section I would be answering some popular frequently asked questions about Substitute For Heavy Cream In Pasta.

FAQs About Substitute For Heavy Cream In Pasta

• Can i substitute milk for heavy cream in pasta?

Yes you can substitute milk for heavy cream in pasta because heavy cream itself contains mostly milk so there won’t be any gap nutritionally. But heavy cream is usually thicker than cream as a result your pasta with milk and not heavy cream would not be very thick but it would be tasty as and great.

• Can you substitute milk for heavy cream in pasta sauce?

Yes you can substitute milk for heavy cream in pasta sauce because heavy cream itself contains mostly milk so there won’t be any gap nutritionally. But heavy cream is usually thicker than cream as a result your pasta with milk and not heavy cream would not be very thick but it would be tasty as and great.

• What can i substitute for heavy cream in pasta?

There are many alternatives you could substitute for heavy cream in pasta, some of these substitutes are;

1. Full fat coconut milk
2. Vegan sour cream
3. White bean cream
4. Non-dairy milk and cornstarch
5. Crème fraiche
6. Cottage cheese
7. Vegan heavy cream

• What to substitute for heavy cream in pasta?

There are many alternatives you could substitute for heavy cream in pasta, some of these substitutes are;

1. Full fat coconut milk
2. Vegan sour cream
3. White bean cream
4. Non-dairy milk and cornstarch
5. Crème fraiche
6. Cottage cheese
7. Vegan heavy cream

• Can you substitute sour cream for heavy cream in pasta?

Yes you can substitute sour cream for heavy cream in pasta but there are very specific type recommended sour cream that serves as a good substitute for heavy cream in pasta, some of these recommended sour cream are vegan sour cream and creme fraiche(a type of sour cream).

• What can I use instead of heavy cream for pasta?

There are many alternatives you could use instead of heavy cream in pasta, some of these substitutes are;

1. Full fat coconut milk
2. Vegan sour cream
3. White bean cream
4. Non-dairy milk and cornstarch
5. Crème fraiche
6. Cottage cheese
7. Vegan heavy cream

• Can I use milk instead of heavy cream for pasta?

Yes you can substitute milk for heavy cream in pasta because heavy cream itself contains mostly milk so there won’t be any gap nutritionally. But heavy cream is usually thicker than cream as a result your pasta with milk and not heavy cream would not be very thick but it would be tasty as and great.

• Can I use milk instead of heavy cream?

In your pasta, you could use milk instead of heavy cream but the result would be less thick with milk than it would have been with heavy cream. But the taste and flavour would be awesome with milk.

Related posts:

5 Best Substitutes For Sour Cream In Cheesecake 7 Heavy Cream Substitutes For Soup You Need To Be Using